Estimate at Completion: Four Methods and When to Use Each

The four EAC formulas (BAC/CPI, CPI x SPI, bottom-up ETC and more) applied to one dataset, management vs statistical EAC, and the TCPI check.

17 min read 5 sections Guide 6 of 8, EVMS Reporting Updated

BACEAC
Estimate at completionOne method: EAC = BAC ÷ CPI

New to this topic?

Read these first to get the most out of this guide:

4
Standard EAC Methods
CPI
Most Common Driver
1.10
TCPI Feasibility Limit
20%
CPI Stabilization Point

Why EAC Matters More Than Any Other Metric

CPI tells you where you have been. SPI tells you how fast you are going. But the question every program manager, customer, and executive actually needs answered is: how much will this program cost when it is done? That is the Estimate at Completion (EAC).

ACPVEV
Earned valueCPI = EV ÷ AC, SPI = EV ÷ PVThe Earned value guide

EAC is the single most consequential number in EVMS. It drives budget decisions, triggers contract modifications, determines whether a program survives its next review, and shapes the careers of everyone involved. An unrealistic EAC (whether too optimistic or too pessimistic) causes bad decisions. Getting it right requires both mathematical rigor and professional judgment.

The four standard methods each make different assumptions about future performance. Understanding those assumptions is the key to choosing the right method, and explaining your choice to stakeholders.

The Four Standard EAC Methods

STEP · KEY POINT · WHY
Standard workThe current best way, written down, so it can be improvedThe Standard work guide
MethodFormulaAssumptionBest Used When
1. CPI-BasedEAC = BAC ÷ CPIFuture cost efficiency will match past cost efficiencyProgram is past 20% complete; no major changes ahead; CPI is stable
2. CPI RemainingEAC = AC + (BAC − EV) ÷ CPIRemaining work will be performed at the current CPISame as Method 1; mathematically equivalent when using cumulative CPI
3. CPI × SPI CompositeEAC = AC + (BAC − EV) ÷ (CPI × SPI)Both cost and schedule inefficiency will persistSchedule delays are driving cost overruns (overtime, extended overhead, resource conflicts)
4. Bottom-Up ETCEAC = AC + Bottom-Up ETCPast performance is not predictive; fresh estimate requiredMajor scope change, new team, different technical approach, or early in program life

Methods 1 and 2 are mathematically equivalent when using cumulative CPI. Method 2 simply makes the logic more explicit: start with what you have already spent (AC), then estimate the remaining cost by dividing remaining work (BAC − EV) by your efficiency (CPI). Most practitioners prefer Method 2 for its transparency.

The Christle Rule and CPI Stability

Research by the DoD (often called the “Christle study”) demonstrated that cumulative CPI stabilizes after approximately 20% of the work is complete. After that point, final CPI is almost always within ±0.10 of the current value. This is why CPI-based EAC methods are most reliable after the 20% completion milestone. Before that point, consider a bottom-up ETC or weight the statistical EAC with greater uncertainty.

Worked Example: Four Methods, One Dataset

Comparing All Four EAC Methods Radar Subsystem: Month 18

Given Data:

MetricValue
Budget at Completion (BAC)$10,000,000
Earned Value (EV)$4,500,000
Actual Cost (AC)$5,400,000
Planned Value (PV)$5,000,000
CPI (cumulative)0.833 (EV ÷ AC)
SPI (cumulative)0.900 (EV ÷ PV)
Bottom-Up ETC (from CAMs)$5,800,000

Method 1 (CPI-Based):

EAC = BAC ÷ CPI = $10,000,000 ÷ 0.833 = $12,005,000

Method 2 (CPI Remaining):

EAC = AC + (BAC − EV) ÷ CPI = $5,400,000 + ($10,000,000 − $4,500,000) ÷ 0.833 = $5,400,000 + $6,603,000 = $12,003,000

(Difference from Method 1 is rounding only: they are mathematically equivalent.)

Method 3 (CPI × SPI Composite):

EAC = AC + (BAC − EV) ÷ (CPI × SPI) = $5,400,000 + $5,500,000 ÷ (0.833 × 0.900) = $5,400,000 + $5,500,000 ÷ 0.750 = $5,400,000 + $7,333,000 = $12,733,000

Method 4 (Bottom-Up ETC):

EAC = AC + ETC = $5,400,000 + $5,800,000 = $11,200,000

MethodEACOverrun vs BACOverrun %
1. CPI-Based$12,005,000+$2,005,000+20.1%
2. CPI Remaining$12,003,000+$2,003,000+20.0%
3. CPI × SPI Composite$12,733,000+$2,733,000+27.3%
4. Bottom-Up ETC$11,200,000+$1,200,000+12.0%

Analysis: The four methods produce EACs ranging from $11.2M to $12.7M, a spread of $1.5M. Method 4 (bottom-up) is the most optimistic, implying the team believes future efficiency will improve to CPI ≥ 0.95. Methods 1 to 2 assume current CPI persists. Method 3 adds schedule-driven cost growth. The PM must decide: is there credible evidence to support the bottom-up optimism, or should the statistical range govern?

Management EAC vs. Statistical EAC

Programs typically maintain two EACs in parallel:

ScopeRequests push at the scope line; only the approved change gets through the gateThe Scope guide
TypeSourceStrengthsWeaknesses
Statistical EACCalculated from CPI, SPI, or CPI × SPIObjective, repeatable, grounded in historical data; resistant to optimism biasCannot account for known future changes: approved scope modifications, new team members, different approach
Management EACBottom-up ETC from CAMs + ACIncorporates expert judgment, known risks, corrective actions, and upcoming changesSusceptible to optimism bias; often lower than statistical EAC without adequate justification

The relationship between these two numbers is itself a diagnostic tool. When management EAC is lower than statistical EAC, the team is claiming they will outperform their historical trend. That claim requires evidence: specific corrective actions, staffing changes, or scope reductions that justify the improvement. When management EAC is higher than statistical EAC, the team has identified risks or scope growth that the indices do not yet reflect.

A persistent gap where management EAC ≤ statistical EAC with no supporting rationale is a red flag. It often indicates the team is “managing to the number” rather than providing an honest forecast.

TCPI: The Feasibility Check

The To-Complete Performance Index (TCPI) answers: what CPI must the team achieve on all remaining work to hit a given target? It is the most powerful reality-check tool in earned value.

4 ERP3 MES2 CONTROL1 SENSE0 PROCESS
ISA-95 levelsFive levels stack from sensors at the bottom to the business system at the top; orders go down and results come up

TCPI = (BAC − EV) ÷ (Target − AC)

Where Target is either BAC (“can we still finish on budget?”) or EAC (“can we hit the current estimate?”).

TCPI Reality Check Using the Same Dataset

TCPI to BAC: (BAC − EV) ÷ (BAC − AC) = ($10M − $4.5M) ÷ ($10M − $5.4M) = $5.5M ÷ $4.6M = 1.196

The team would need a CPI of 1.20 on all remaining work to finish at $10M. Current CPI is 0.833. This is not feasible: finishing on budget is effectively impossible.

TCPI to Management EAC ($11.2M): ($10M − $4.5M) ÷ ($11.2M − $5.4M) = $5.5M ÷ $5.8M = 0.948

The team needs a CPI of 0.95 to hit their bottom-up EAC. Current CPI is 0.833. This requires a 14% improvement in efficiency, ambitious but not impossible if corrective actions are credible.

As a rule of thumb: if TCPI ≥ 1.10, the target is almost certainly unachievable. If TCPI is between 1.00 and 1.10, it is theoretically possible but requires sustained improvement. If TCPI ≤ 1.00, the target is achievable at or below current performance levels.

The Optimism Trap

When management EAC is lower than every statistical method, and TCPI to that EAC exceeds 1.05, the program is likely exhibiting optimism bias. Government reviewers will compare TCPI against CPI and ask: “What specific actions justify performing 15% better than your track record on every remaining dollar?” If the answer is vague, expect the customer to impose a higher EAC.

The Bottom Line

Four EAC methods exist because no single formula fits every situation. CPI-based methods (1 and 2) work best after the 20% completion point when trends are stable. The composite method (3) captures schedule-driven cost growth. Bottom-up ETC (4) is essential when conditions have changed. Always compare management EAC against statistical EAC and use TCPI to reality-check the result. If your TCPI exceeds 1.10, your target is a fantasy. Next: Integrated Baseline Review, validating the plan before execution begins.

Frequently asked questions

Which EAC method should I use?

It depends on your assessment of future performance. If you believe remaining work will follow the same cost efficiency trend, use EAC = BAC ÷ CPI. If you believe both cost and schedule inefficiency will persist, use EAC = AC + (BAC-EV) ÷ (CPI×SPI). If conditions have fundamentally changed (scope change, new team, different approach), use a bottom-up ETC. Most programs report multiple EACs for comparison, with the management EAC reflecting the PM's informed judgment.

What is the difference between management EAC and statistical EAC?

Statistical EAC is calculated mechanically from CPI and SPI data: it is objective and repeatable. Management EAC incorporates human judgment: known risks, approved changes not yet in the baseline, anticipated efficiencies, or planned corrective actions. The two should be compared monthly. If management EAC is significantly more optimistic than statistical EAC, the PM must explain why: 'we expect to do better than our track record' requires strong justification.

What is TCPI and how does it relate to EAC?

TCPI (To-Complete Performance Index) answers: 'What CPI must we achieve on all remaining work to hit a target EAC?' The formula is TCPI = (BAC − EV) ÷ (Target − AC), where Target is either BAC (to finish on budget) or EAC (to finish at the estimate). If TCPI exceeds 1.10, the target is generally unachievable: the team would need to be 10%+ more efficient than plan on every remaining dollar.

Share this guide: LinkedIn X Follow SymplProcess on LinkedIn

Take this to a room

The running order

For CAMs and control staff. They should leave able to compute all four EACs on one dataset and to use TCPI to test the management number.

7 beats · 12 min
  1. 1

    Why EAC matters more than any other metric

    CPI describes the past. EAC is the only number that commits anyone to anything.

    • It drives funding requests, contract actions and management decisions.
    • Getting it wrong late is far more expensive than getting it wrong early.
    • Every other metric exists to make this one credible.

    Ask the room What EAC are we reporting, and how was it derived?

  2. 2

    Four methods because no formula fits everything

    They are not competing. They answer slightly different questions.

    • BAC over CPI: simplest, assumes past efficiency continues.
    • AC plus remaining work over CPI: the same assumption, applied only to what is left.
    • The composite, using CPI times SPI: captures schedule-driven cost growth.
    • Bottom-up ETC: when conditions have genuinely changed.
  3. 3

    Run all four on the same data

    The spread between them is itself the finding.

    • Four numbers that agree means the trend is stable and you can rely on it.
    • Four numbers far apart means schedule pressure or a changed situation.
    • Never present one method alone.
  4. 4

    After twenty per cent, trust CPI

    The Christle finding again: cumulative CPI stabilises after about a fifth of the work.

    • Before that point, prefer a bottom-up ETC or weight the statistical methods carefully.
    • After it, CPI-based EACs are the most reliable ones you have.
    • This is why the 20 per cent milestone gets its own review on well-run programmes.
  5. 5

    Management EAC versus statistical EAC

    They are allowed to differ. What is not allowed is differing without a reason.

    • Management EAC reflects planned actions. Statistical EAC reflects the track record.
    • Show both, and explain the gap with specific actions.
    • A gap with no named actions is optimism, not a forecast.
  6. 6

    The optimism trap

    There is a specific test, and the customer will run it whether or not you do.

    • If management EAC is lower than every statistical method and TCPI to it exceeds 1.05, that is optimism bias.
    • The reviewer asks: what specific actions justify performing 15 per cent better than your record, on every remaining dollar?
    • If the answer is vague, expect a higher EAC to be imposed.

    Ask the room Could we answer that question about our own EAC today?

  7. 7

    TCPI is the feasibility gate

    One number decides whether the EAC is a plan or a wish.

    • Above 1.10, the target is a fantasy. Say so before the customer does.
    • Compare TCPI against demonstrated CPI, every month.
    • Change the EAC or change the work. Those are the only two options.

    Ask the room What is our TCPI to the current management EAC?